logo

Orange vs. Apple vs. Mango, which juice should diabetics be most careful about?

Orange vs. Apple vs. Mango, which juice should diabetics be most careful with?

Reporter Isulbi's story
 
 
 •
Orange vs. Apple vs. Mango, which juice should diabetics be most careful about?
 

If you have diabetes, you should be cautious when consuming 'mango juice' made from fresh fruit. Recently, an analysis of the glycemic index (GI) and glycemic load (GL) of fresh fruit juices made from mango, apple, papaya, and orange revealed that mango juice has the highest values in both indices.

The team of Professor Yapo Haipolyte Kouadio from the Department of Food Science at Alassane Ouattara University in Ivory Coast conducted a study to identify more suitable fresh fruit juice options for diabetic patients.

 

Fruits are high in sugar, but they are also rich in fiber, vitamins, and minerals, which help prevent chronic diseases. Experts recommend that diabetics consume an appropriate amount of fruit. However, fresh fruit juices have lower fiber content than whole fruits, reducing their benefits. The research team analyzed blood sugar and glycemic index levels to determine whether it is safe for diabetes patients to consume fresh fruit juices made from the most commonly consumed fruits such as mango, apple, papaya, and orange at the Abijan Anti-Diabetes Center.


The glycemic index is a measure of how quickly blood sugar levels rise after eating a food. It is calculated by setting the blood sugar increase speed after consuming 50g of simple glucose as 100, and then expressing the relative speed when consuming 50g of carbohydrates from a specific food. The glycemic load is a value that considers the amount of food consumed, calculated by multiplying the glycemic index by the amount of carbohydrate intake and then dividing by 100.

 

The research team conducted an experiment on 16 participants who had normal fasting blood glucose levels and were not obese. They consumed mango, apple, papaya, orange juice, and a control solution (250 mL of water mixed with 50g of glucose), and their blood glucose levels were measured. All fresh fruit juices were adjusted to contain 50g of carbohydrates. The participants fasted for 12 hours before measuring their fasting blood glucose levels, and blood samples were collected at 15, 30, 45, 60, 90, and 120 minutes after consuming each of the test foods.

 

The analysis showed that both blood sugar and insulin levels were highest after consuming mango juice.

 

The glycemic index was ▲mango juice (56.41), ▲apple juice (31.50), ▲papaya juice (49.67), ▲orange juice (42.97). The glycemic index is classified as high when 70 or above, medium between 55 and 69, and low when 55 or below. Only mango juice fell into the 'medium' category. The rest all had low glycemic index values.

The sugar content index for the fruit juices is as follows: mango juice (7.46), apple juice (2.56), papaya juice (5.06), and orange juice (3.91), with mango juice being the highest. However, all fresh fruit juices had sugar content indices below 10, classifying them as 'low'.

The research team stated that "the different blood sugar responses were due to the varying characteristics of the sugars contained in each fruit, interactions with other nutrients, and phenolic compounds."

 

Professor Ko Audio stated, "The glycemic index of fresh fruit juice is relatively low, so it can be consumed by diabetics," but also added, "Among them, mango juice has a relatively high glycemic index and blood sugar levels, so it is recommended to drink it only occasionally."

Meanwhile, the results of this study were recently published in the International Journal of Nutritional Food Science, the 'NFS Journal'.

 

=================

Orange. Apple. Mango.

It seems that the sugar content is highest in mangoes.

 

Among these, apple juice is the lowest.

 

Since you're going to have juice anyway

For those with diabetes

Drink less mango juice, or...

Please enjoy with oranges and apples.

 

 

8
0
Comments 20
  • Profile Image
    지영도영
    사과주스가 생각보다 낮네요
    • Profile Image
      하루=즐겁게+행복하게+웃으며✌
      Author
      사과주스 맛도좋은데
      역시나 공복에 사과라고 하잖아요 
      사과 낮아요 
  • Profile Image
    프카쟁이
    당뇨환자는 사실 과일쥬스 다 조심해야 할거 같긴 해요;;;
    근데 일반 즙 쥬스들은 괜찮나 싶더라구요. 양파라던가 이런거 100% 다른거 안들어갔다고 해도 믿기가 좀 그래가지고 
    • Profile Image
      하루=즐겁게+행복하게+웃으며✌
      Author
      당뇨환자들은 과일도 주스도 다 조심해야하죠 
      즙이요? 그러네요 
      양파즙 같은경우에도 달달하니, 당분이 꽤 될듯 한데요 
  • Profile Image
    오둥씨
    혈당에 좋은 과일은 껍질채 꼭꼭 씹어서
    먹는게 젤루 좋은 것 같아요.
    망고 좋아하는데 당도는 높지요
    이건 껍질도 못먹어요 ㅋㅋ
    • Profile Image
      하루=즐겁게+행복하게+웃으며✌
      Author
      맞아요 주스도 맛있긴 한데
      껍질째 먹을 수 있는 과일은 그렇게 먹는게 더 좋죠
  • Profile Image
    안레몬
    망고가 제일 당뇨환자에게 부담이 높군요. 먹고싶다면 사과주스가 좋네요. 잘보고 갑니다.
    • Profile Image
      하루=즐겁게+행복하게+웃으며✌
      Author
      저희 아버지는 당 갖고 계시는데요 
      주스는 아예 안 드세요
  • Profile Image
    애플
    역시 달콤한 망고가 안 좋네요
    사과도 주스보다 생으로 껍질째 먹는게
    좋을꺼 같네요 ~~
    • Profile Image
      하루=즐겁게+행복하게+웃으며✌
      Author
      주스는 다 맛있는데
      저도 사과는 껍질째 아삭아삭 먹는게 좋아요
  • Profile Image
    말해뭐해
    과일 주스는 당뇨환자한텐 다 안 좋은 것 같아요.
    전원 당근 주스를 추천합니다
    • Profile Image
      하루=즐겁게+행복하게+웃으며✌
      Author
      맞아요 특히 당뇨 환자분들은 과즙은 
      더 당분이 올라간다고 하잖아요
  • Profile Image
    bi
    망고가 가장 당이 많군요
    먹을때 주의해야겠네요 
    • Profile Image
      하루=즐겁게+행복하게+웃으며✌
      Author
      망고가 주스도 다양한 거 같아요 스무디도 그렇고
      좀 덜 마시면 되겠죠
  • Profile Image
    손주연
    좋은 정보 감사합니다 ㅎㅎ 
    저도 관심 분야인데 참고하겠습니다 건강하세요 
    • Profile Image
      하루=즐겁게+행복하게+웃으며✌
      Author
      건강을 생각해서 단 거 말고
      사과 주스 드시면 될 거 같아요
  • Profile Image
    ..💕한밧드(0:01발송)
    음 그렇군요 공복혈당이 높은 저는 망고는 처다도 보지 말아야 겠네요
    • Profile Image
      하루=즐겁게+행복하게+웃으며✌
      Author
      망고는 열대과일
      열대과일들이 항상 달고 당이 높죠
  • 은하수
    사과주스는 달긴 한데 당은 글케 안높네요 
    망고는 안되겠군요
    • Profile Image
      하루=즐겁게+행복하게+웃으며✌
      Author
      회사에서 사과 주스 먹잖아요 직원들하고
      마셔 보니 정말 덜 달아요