logo

Frying vs boiling vs stir-frying… Which is the worst for 'air quality'?

Frying vs boiling vs stir-frying… Which is the worst for 'air quality'?

Story of Reporter Choi Ji-woo
 
Frying vs boiling vs stir-frying… Which is the worst for 'air quality'?
 

Fine dust and harmful gases generated during cooking degrade indoor air quality and can cause respiratory diseases and cardiovascular conditions. Recent studies have shown that indoor air pollution levels vary depending on the cooking method. Considering indoor air quality, what is the best cooking method?

 

The atmospheric science research team at the University of Birmingham in the UK analyzed indoor air quality changes according to five cooking methods: boiling, frying, stir-frying, baking, and air frying.

 

The research team cooked 120g of chicken breast a total of 90 times according to each method. ▲24 times grilling ▲20 times stir-frying ▲16 times deep-frying ▲16 times boiling ▲14 times air frying. Afterward, they measured indoor air pollution levels using an optical aerosol spectrometer and a proton transfer reaction time-of-flight mass spectrometer. These two measurement methods detect volatile organic compounds (VOCs) and particulate matter (PM), which are representative indoor air pollutants. According to the UK Environment Agency, particulate matter affects the lungs and heart, increasing the risk of ▲heart attack ▲arrhythmia ▲cough ▲worsening of asthma. Volatile organic compounds can cause various health issues such as ▲throat irritation ▲headaches ▲liver damage ▲heart damage ▲cancer.

 

The analysis showed that the air fryer caused the least indoor air pollution compared to the other four cooking methods.

 

The maximum concentration of particulate matter by cooking method was in the order of roasting 92.9, stir-frying 26.7, deep-frying 7.7, boiling 0.7, and air frying 0.6. The concentration of volatile organic compounds was in the order of roasting 260 ppm, deep-frying 230 ppb, stir-frying 110 ppb, boiling 30 ppb, and air frying 20 ppb.

Dr. Christian Pang, who led the research, said, "Cooking with an air fryer instead of frying or sautéing food in a pan can significantly reduce exposure to indoor pollutants." An air fryer uses a high-speed fan inside the device to evenly distribute hot air, making the food crispy. Because it uses much less oil than other cooking methods, it releases less smoke into the air. Since cooking occurs inside a sealed machine, it effectively prevents hot oil and smoke from being released onto walls or into the atmosphere.

Meanwhile, the results of this study were recently published in 'Indoor Air'.

 
Frying vs boiling vs stir-frying… Which is the worst for 'air quality'?
 
===========
While cooking at home
The smell of gas and ventilation.
Even if you do it
It's always a concern.
 
Air fryer is the best.
It seems to be less contaminated.
7
0
Comments 18
  • Profile Image
    다노맘
    에어프라이어가 젤 낫군요.
    주로 사용해봐야겠어요
    • Profile Image
      하루=즐겁게+행복하게+웃으며✌
      Author
      간간이 사용하고 있는데
      훨씬 좋기는 한 거 같아요
  • Profile Image
    깐데또까
     굽기가 제일 심할것 같았어요 연기도 나고~
     제일 좋은건 에어 프라이어가 제일 좋은 조리
     도구 였네요 
    • Profile Image
      하루=즐겁게+행복하게+웃으며✌
      Author
      가스 불에서 있을 때 좀 걱정되기도 해요
      남편도 음식 할 때 조심하라고 하고요
  • Profile Image
    감사와행복
    앞으로는 에에프라이어를 더 이용하도록 노력해야겠네요 정보 감사합니다 
    • Profile Image
      하루=즐겁게+행복하게+웃으며✌
      Author
      음식 하는 거 에어프라이어도 
      같이 사용하면 좋을 거 같아요
  • Profile Image
    신혜림
    에어프라이어 잘 사용해요.
    기름으로 하는 것 보단 좋네요
    • Profile Image
      하루=즐겁게+행복하게+웃으며✌
      Author
      그렇죠 기름에 하면 그 냄새도 그렇고
       제 몸에 또 들어가는 거 같아서요
  • Profile Image
    애플
    굽기가 젤 안 좋은거 군요
    요리할때 신경써야 겠어요 ~
    • Profile Image
      하루=즐겁게+행복하게+웃으며✌
      Author
      굽기 할 때는 특히나 주의해야 될 거 같아요
      근데 음식을 하게게 되는게 아 매일 해야 되니까 걱정이에요
  • Profile Image
    지영도영
    추운 겨울철이라 요리하면서도 더 신경쓰이긴하네요
    • Profile Image
      하루=즐겁게+행복하게+웃으며✌
      Author
      집에서 요리할 때 특히나 신경 많이 쓰고 있는데도 
      어쩔 수 없는 일인 거 같아요
  • Profile Image
    비니비니
    에어프라이기 더 열심히 사용해야겠네요
    없음  안되는 필수템이네요
    • Profile Image
      하루=즐겁게+행복하게+웃으며✌
      Author
      가스 불도 사용하고
       에어프라이어도 골고루 사용하면 좋겠죠
      
  • Profile Image
    bi
    에어프라이어가 오염도가 가장 낮네요
    요리하면서 주의해야겠네요 
    • Profile Image
      하루=즐겁게+행복하게+웃으며✌
      Author
      가장 오염도가 낮아서요 그나마 다행인데요
      그래도 요리를 해야 되니깐 가스 불은 참 걱정이에요
  • Profile Image
    은하수
    에어프라이가 오염도가 낮군요
    기름에 튀기거나 볶는 등의 요리에서 요리흄이 발생해 안좋다고 하지요
    • Profile Image
      하루=즐겁게+행복하게+웃으며✌
      Author
      에어프라이어 자주 사용하면 좋겠어요
      튀김 음식은 되도록이면 덜 먹어야죠